The Whey Station(ary)
544 Main St, Middletown, United States
🛍 American, North American, Cheese, Sandwiches, Drinks
544 Main St, Middletown, United States
🛍 American, North American, Cheese, Sandwiches, Drinks
At 544 Main St, Middletown, United States, find the hidden gem that is The Whey Station(ary). It's a cafe where every menu item promises an unforgettable culinary experience. A coveted rating of 4.6 and an army of satisfied patrons reflected in 355 reviews – we are not just a restaurant, but a landmark of great taste and exceptional dining. Join us and partake in this unique gastronomic adventure.
The first time here sad, the last. The decor was dia de los Muertos inspired w/bright fiesta like colors that were fun! Our server, Kiely, was friendly. They do not offer beer flights. We went with the Alvarium Ecto Cooler a Spoke Spy Tepache Mode cider. They were crisp colors that were surprisingly cool! Hubby thought the ecto was okay. I had a very difficult time to finish the Rector. The sample was full of pint, not so much. There was a spicy floral taste that we could not identify. (the drinks are not their fault For apps we had the Spinat Artichoke Dip (came w/ homemade chips aka Irish Fries and Bruffalos (Buffalo brüssels). The dip had carvings of artichokes (yes!, but was very, very cream cheese forward and had zero taste except A LOT of black pepper, so much you could see it on the dip. Dip bowl was super hot, but the bathroom, not so much. We liked it so much that we didn't finish it. Brussels was decent, but needed some more buffalo sauce (imo, as they were very slightly coated, maybe add a little more blue cheese crumbs. Share the Ella Sandwich bags. Deads were super hot crispy. Everything seemed ok w/the sandwich (bread was crispy, buttery warm until you took a bite. The prosciutto inside was fat COLD. Feige... The cheese started too congealed when we got it. Super, super disappointing. Grilled cheese is suspected when it is pulled apart, not this? You're a grilled cheese place for shame!
Call +18607402403 for questions or prices.
The full menu from The Whey Station(ary) in Middletown!
All prices are estimations.
It was pleasant. Food was good, except soup was cold. Sweet waitress with a good personality. The service was good.
Food was great, the service was even better. Kimber made a great job and was very attentive to details. It's refreshing because it's less often that you get this kind of hospitality.
I had a very good experience here. Great food for cheese lovers. I had the Mac and cheese with beef that was amazing. The buffalo dip was really good, it wasn't sharp. The food and the staff were great. In any case, it'll be back!
I took my 90-year-old grandmother here because she loves cheese and potatoes. She won?t stop talking about how much she loved it. The people were friendly, the environment was youthful and hip, and they have delicious craft sodas. Will definitely come back next time I?m in town!
If you?ve ever craved a sense of comfort with a sense of whimsy, The Whey Station(ary) should be placed upon your short list. Tater tots and grilled cheese sandwiches are the main attractions, and for good reason they are lip smacking and indulgent! Pictured is The Shorty, which is short ribs wrapped in a five cheese blend, garnished with garlic aioli and caramelized onions, which was astoundingly good! The cook made certain to put heaping helpings of each ingredient and then crisped all of the extra cheese that melted over the sides. It was like being a kid on a ditch day at home with mom combined with the feeling of a summer weekend as an adult. Also seen here is the Avomelt, guacamole, bacon, and more garlic aioli. Incredible! The tater tots were uniformly crisp, as well. Unique beers were on tap, the restaurant was safely spaced, and the service was incredibly attentive. Bravo! See you again and SOON!
Learned about The Whey Station from a Food Network show, everything was really great! I recommend the Brussel Sprouts anyway they serve them. Short Rib grilled cheese with tomatoe bisque amazing. Staff wonderful, following all safety protocols. Thank you.
Got a notification on my phone from Google Maps that I should try this place. Ended up going with a co-worker and wasn't disappointed. Got the Barlow with Cheese Bacon Tons and Avery soda and it was delicious. Great location and atmosphere. The place has a wheelchair accessible entrance and seating, not sure about the bathroom since I didn't need to use it. Can't wait to go back!
